 | | Wagner | 100 | | 11-7 |  | | St. Francis (PA) | 83 | | 8-9 | | Mar 4, 1986 | |  | | Long Island | 57 | | 4-13 |  | | Fairleigh Dickinson | 86 | | 15-4 | | Mar 4, 1986 | |  | | St. Francis (NY) | 64 | | 4-13 |  | | Marist | 83 | | 14-5 | | Mar 4, 1986 | |  | | Loyola (MD) | 69 | | 10-7 |  | | Robert Morris | 75 | | 7-11 | | Mar 4, 1986 | |
| | | Marist | 60 | | 14-5 | | | Robert Morris | 55 | | 7-11 | | Mar 5, 1986 | | | | Wagner | 77 | | 11-7 | | | Fairleigh Dickinson | 81 | | 15-4 | | Mar 5, 1986 | |
| | | Marist | 57 | | 14-5 | | | Fairleigh Dickinson | 56 | | 15-4 | | Mar 6, 1986 | |
|
