 | | UIC | 107 | | 6-12 |  | | Butler | 97 | | 12-5 | | Mar 2, 1996 | |  | | Detroit Mercy | 67 | | 10-9 |  | | Wright St. | 61 | | 8-9 | | Mar 2, 1996 | |  | | Green Bay | 58 | | 17-1 |  | | Loyola Chicago | 48 | | 5-12 | | Mar 2, 1996 | |  | | Milwaukee | 78 | | 5-12 |  | | Northern Illinois | 80 | | 13-6 | | Mar 2, 1996 | |
| | | Green Bay | 50 | | 17-1 | | | Detroit Mercy | 56 | | 10-9 | | Mar 3, 1996 | | | | Northern Illinois | 95 | | 13-6 | | | UIC | 60 | | 6-12 | | Mar 3, 1996 | |
| | | Northern Illinois | 84 | | 13-6 | | | Detroit Mercy | 63 | | 10-9 | | Mar 5, 1996 | |
|
