 | | East Carolina | 54 | | 6-9 |  | | UNC Wilmington | 75 | | 7-9 | | Feb 28, 1986 | |
|  | | American | 60 | | 3-12 |  | | George Mason | 68 | | 12-5 | | Mar 1, 1986 | |  | | William & Mary | 50 | | 3-11 |  | | Richmond | 61 | | 13-3 | | Mar 1, 1986 | |  | | James Madison | 67 | | 3-12 |  | | Navy | 81 | | 16-1 | | Mar 1, 1986 | |
| | | Richmond | 60 | | 13-3 | | | George Mason | 62 | | 12-5 | | Mar 2, 1986 | | | | UNC Wilmington | 60 | | 7-9 | | | Navy | 62 | | 16-1 | | Mar 2, 1986 | |
| | | Navy | 72 | | 16-1 | | | George Mason | 61 | | 12-5 | | Mar 3, 1986 | |
|
