 | | Colgate | 64 | | 6-10 |  | | Navy | 59 | | 8-7 | | Mar 4, 2009 | |  | | Lafayette | 56 | | 4-11 |  | | American | 78 | | 16-1 | | Mar 4, 2009 | |  | | Bucknell | 75 | | 4-10 |  | | Holy Cross | 56 | | 11-3 | | Mar 4, 2009 | |  | | Lehigh | 50 | | 5-9 |  | | Army | 53 | | 7-9 | | Mar 4, 2009 | |
| | | Army | 60 | | 7-9 | | | American | 61 | | 16-1 | | Mar 8, 2009 | | | | Colgate | 61 | | 6-10 | | | Holy Cross | 44 | | 11-3 | | Mar 8, 2009 | |
| | | Holy Cross | 57 | | 11-3 | | | American | 73 | | 16-1 | | Mar 13, 2009 | |
|
