 | | Marist | 40 | | 5-15 |  | | Iona | 43 | | 7-12 | | Mar 6, 2009 | |  | | Loyola (MD) | 68 | | 7-12 |  | | Canisius | 74 | | 5-15 | | Mar 6, 2009 | |
|  | | St. Peters | 58 | | 8-11 |  | | Rider | 67 | | 13-7 | | Mar 7, 2009 | |  | | Niagara | 50 | | 16-5 | | | Marist | 79 | | 5-15 | | Mar 7, 2009 | |  | | Manhattan | 61 | | 9-9 |  | | Fairfield | 68 | | 10-10 | | Mar 7, 2009 | | | | Canisius | 77 | | 5-15 |  | | Siena | 52 | | 19-2 | | Mar 7, 2009 | |
| | | Fairfield | 80 | | 10-10 | | | Siena | 65 | | 19-2 | | Mar 8, 2009 | | | | Rider | 89 | | 13-7 | | | Niagara | 93 | | 16-5 | | Mar 8, 2009 | |
| | | Niagara | 77 | | 16-5 | | | Siena | 70 | | 19-2 | | Mar 9, 2009 | |
|
