 | | Green Bay | 50 | | 3-12 |  | | Missouri State | 63 | | 11-5 | | Mar 6, 1986 | |  | | Northern Iowa | 68 | | 3-12 |  | | Cleveland State | 73 | | 16-1 | | Mar 6, 1986 | |  | | Valparaiso | 65 | | 5-10 |  | | Eastern Illinois | 85 | | 10-7 | | Mar 6, 1986 | |  | | Western Illinois | 68 | | 7-8 |  | | UIC | 71 | | 8-8 | | Mar 6, 1986 | |
| | | Eastern Illinois | 71 | | 10-7 | | | Missouri State | 67 | | 11-5 | | Mar 7, 1986 | | | | UIC | 84 | | 8-8 | | | Cleveland State | 100 | | 16-1 | | Mar 7, 1986 | |
| | | Eastern Illinois | 66 | | 10-7 | | | Cleveland State | 70 | | 16-1 | | Mar 8, 1986 | |
|
